Guide · Partners
How to talk with your partner about a big decision you disagree on
Big decisions can feel like a contest. Here’s how to make it a problem you solve together.
Take your time
Big decisions rarely need settling in one talk. Agree to come back to it.
Cool down, then talk ›What you might want to sayWe need to decide this tonight.
Porcupine · Pause when floodedA deadline of tonight makes the choice feel urgent. A week to think, and a day to talk again, takes the pressure off you both.
What might land betterCan we each think about it this week, and talk again on Sunday?
Say what matters to you, and why
The worry behind your position is easier to work with than the position alone.
Say what’s underneath ›What you might want to sayI’m not moving to the suburbs. End of discussion.
Porcupine · Interests, not positions“End of discussion” closes the talk. Your worry about leaving your friends and job says what’s at stake for you, and that’s something you can solve together.
What might land betterI’m worried about moving away from my friends and my job. That’s what makes me hesitant.
Understand what matters to them
Ask what’s behind their view, and say back what you heard.
Understand before answering ›What you might want to sayWhy would you even want that?
Porcupine · Ask real questions“Why would you even” makes the question a judgment. “What’s drawing you” is curious, and asks for their reason, not a defense.
What might land betterWhat’s drawing you to the suburbs?
Look for the reasons behind each position
“I want a yard” and “I need to be near work” can both be met in more than one way.
Us against the problem ›List options before you judge them
Write them down together, even the ones that seem unlikely, before you rule any out. The best answer may be one neither of you started with.
Stay open ›Ask, don’t pressure
Guilt or an ultimatum may get a yes, but not one either of you can feel good about.
Ask, don’t pressure ›What you might want to sayIf you really loved me, you’d do this.
Porcupine · Ask without guilt or leverage“If you really loved me” ties their love to their answer. Saying how much it matters, and that you’ll keep talking, asks without pressure.
What might land betterThis matters a lot to me. Can we keep talking until we find something we both feel good about?
If you still disagree
Some decisions involve real tradeoffs. A counselor can help you talk it through, and what you decide is up to the two of you.
Their words, their choice ›
The common mistake
Deciding alone, then announcing it
Researching every option and arriving with an answer can feel efficient, but it leaves your partner only a yes or a no. Bring them in while it’s still open.
Us against the problem ›If it doesn’t go the way you hoped
What they might say, and what you could say back.
If they sayYou always get your way.
You could sayI don’t want that this time. Tell me what matters most to you, and let’s start there.
If they sayI don’t want to talk about it.
You could sayOkay. Could we pick a time this week? I’d rather not decide it without you.
If they sayFine, do whatever you want.
You could sayI don’t want to decide this alone. What you think matters to me.
Putting it together
The whole message, before and after.
What you might want to sayI’m not moving to the suburbs. End of discussion.
Porcupine · Interests, not positionsYour worry, a question about what draws them and a place that might fit both: together, they turn a standoff into a problem you solve side by side.
What might land betterI’m worried about moving away from my friends and my job. That’s what makes me hesitant. What’s drawing you to the suburbs? Maybe we can find a place that gives you a yard and keeps me near work.
Run a Quills Check on yours
Write what you want to say to your partner, however it comes out. I’ll show you if the quills are up, and a version with them down.
The Quills Check needs JavaScript. Please turn it on and reload the page.
Common questions
What if we have a deadline?
Agree on when you’ll decide, and use the time until then to talk. A set date beats a decision made in the middle of an argument.
What if one of us cares much more?
Say how much it matters to each of you. The one who cares more may get more say on this one, and the other on the next.
What if we really can’t agree?
Look for a trial or a smaller step, like renting before you buy. A counselor can also help you think it through together.
Know someone this would help?
Send them this guide. The link shows its title and one of its examples.
Find the words with Porcupine
PorcupineIn a porcupine chat, a coach helps you each say what matters before you decide together.
Porcupine is coming soon. Sign up to be one of the first to try it.
Just your email. How we handle it
From the data
- How much time couples spend together, and how much of it is talkingWho fills your day?
Related guides
Guides are general information, not legal, financial or professional advice. If you’re afraid of how someone might react, put your safety first and talk to someone you trust (Safety first).