Guide · In-laws
How to respond to unsolicited advice from your in-laws
Here’s how to respond kindly in the moment, without promising to take advice you won’t.
Take a breath
In the moment, you don’t have to defend your choices. A short pause keeps you from answering with an edge.
Cool down, then talk ›What you might want to sayOh, here we go.
Porcupine · Pause when flooded“Here we go” says the eye-roll out loud. A simple “Mm, I hear you” gives you a moment before you answer.
What might land betterMm, I hear you.
Thank them for caring
Acknowledging their care doesn’t mean agreeing.
Us against the problem ›What you might want to saySure, whatever.
Porcupine · Say what you appreciate“Sure, whatever” sounds like you stopped listening. Thanking them for caring takes the care in, without taking the advice.
What might land betterThanks, I know you care.
Say what you’ve decided
Kind, and clear that it’s your call.
Honest and hearable ›What you might want to sayWe don’t need your advice, thanks.
Porcupine · Say what you appreciate“We don’t need your advice” turns down the person along with the advice. “I know you care” keeps the person, and “we’ve thought it through” keeps your answer.
What might land betterThanks, I know you care. We’ve thought it through, and we’re going to stick with what’s working for us.
Move the conversation on
A new topic is a fine way to close it.
What you might want to sayCan we please talk about anything else?
Porcupine · Repair attempts“Anything else” says the topic’s unwelcome. Asking about their trip changes it with a warm question.
What might land betterHow was your trip?
Talk with your partner later
If it’s a pattern, agree on how you’ll both handle it, and who will raise it if needed.
Us against the problem ›What you might want to sayYour dad did it again.
Porcupine · Make it a shared problem“Your dad did it again” puts your partner on the spot. Working it out together makes it a plan you share.
What might land betterCould we work out together how to handle the parenting advice when it comes up?
Pick your moments
Some advice is easy to let pass. Save a bigger conversation for what really matters to you.
Agreement isn’t the only good ending ›If it keeps happening
A calm, private conversation about the pattern may help.
Honest and hearable ›How to set a boundary with your in-laws ›
The common mistake
Arguing every point
Defending each choice in detail can turn a passing comment into a debate, and tells them the advice is worth debating. A short, kind answer usually ends it faster.
Cool down, then talk ›If it doesn’t go the way you hoped
What they might say, and what you could say back.
If they sayI’m just saying, in my day…
You could sayThings were different then. We’re happy with how it’s going.
If they sayYou’ll see I’m right.
You could sayMaybe! We’ll find out. For now, this is what we’re doing.
If they sayI’m only trying to help.
You could sayI know you are, and I appreciate it. We’ve got this one.
Putting it together
The whole message, before and after.
What you might want to sayWe don’t need your advice, thanks.
Porcupine · Say what you appreciateThanks for the care, a clear word that you’ve decided, and a new topic. They’re heard, and the conversation moves on.
What might land betterThanks, I know you care. We’ve thought it through, and we’re going to stick with what’s working for us. How was your trip?
Run a Quills Check on yours
Write what you want to say, however it comes out. I’ll show you if the quills are up, and a version with them down.
The Quills Check needs JavaScript. Please turn it on and reload the page.
Common questions
What if the advice is actually good?
You can take it. Advice you didn’t ask for isn’t always wrong, and “That’s a good idea, thanks” costs nothing.
What if they keep repeating it?
Use the same kind, short line each time. If it continues, talk with your partner about a private conversation.
What if they say it in front of the kids?
Keep it light and brief in the moment, and talk about it privately later.
Know someone this would help?
Send them this guide. The link shows its title and one of its examples.
Find the words with Porcupine
PorcupineWhen it comes up again, I’ll remember what you’ve said and help you answer kindly, and keep it your call.
Porcupine is coming soon. Sign up to be one of the first to try it.
Just your email. How we handle it
More for the season
- Get through the holidays with your family, without a fightWho goes where, gifts, grandparents and the dinner table, in the order they come up.
Related guides
- How to set a boundary with your in-lawsIn-laws
- How to decline an invitation from your in-lawsIn-laws
- How to respond to a text that sounds passive-aggressiveAny relationship
- How to respond to an intrusive questionStrangers and acquaintances
Guides are general information, not legal, financial or professional advice. If you’re afraid of how someone might react, put your safety first and talk to someone you trust (Safety first).