Guides › Family › Anyone in the family
Guide · Anyone in the family
What to do when a family member keeps bringing up the past
When the same old story keeps coming back, it may be because part of it still feels unheard.
You don’t have to settle it on the spot
If it comes up in the middle of dinner, you can pause it without dismissing it.
Cool down, then talk ›What you might want to sayHere we go again.
Porcupine · Pause when flooded“Here we go again” waves it off. Asking for a time this week sets it aside without setting them aside.
What might land betterI want to talk about this properly. Can we find a time this week?
Listen for what still hurts
Ask what it was like for them, and say back what you heard. Feeling understood can matter more than settling who was right.
Understand before answering ›What you might want to sayYou need to let it go.
Porcupine · Reflect back first“You need to let it go” asks them to stop feeling it. Saying back what you heard, and checking you got it right, shows you’re listening.
What might land betterIt sounds like you felt I didn’t think it mattered. Is that right?
Ask what they need now
Ask instead of guessing: an apology, an explanation, or just to be heard?
Check before assuming ›What you might want to sayWhat do you want from me?
Porcupine · Ask real questions“What do you want from me?” can sound like a challenge. “What would help, now?” asks the same thing, as a real question.
What might land betterWhat would help, now? I’d really like to know.
Own your part, if you had one
If something you did hurt them, say so plainly, without a “but” and without “that was years ago.”
Own your part ›What you might want to sayAre we really doing this again? That was fifteen years ago. Get over it.
Porcupine · Own your partNaming the graduation itself, and that you wish you’d been there, owns what happened. It answers the hurt instead of the timing.
What might land betterI’m sorry I missed your graduation. I know it still hurts, and I wish I’d been there.
Share your side after they feel heard
If you remember it differently, say so, and talk about what happened rather than who they are.
Describe, don’t diagnose ›What you might want to sayYou always twist what happened.
Porcupine · The behavior, not the person“You always twist what happened” is about them. “I remember it differently” keeps your side about the memory, and asking first makes room for both.
What might land betterI remember that week a bit differently. Can I tell you how it looked to me?
Talk about what would help now
Ask what would help you both move forward, like a promise for next time, or a way to mark the day differently.
Us against the problem ›If it still comes up
Some hurts come back now and then, even after a good talk. Hearing it again with patience is part of living with it well.
Agreement isn’t the only good ending ›
The common mistake
Telling them to get over it
“That was years ago” can feel like a fair point, but it tells them the hurt doesn’t count, and it tends to bring the story back louder. Hearing it out is usually what lets it rest.
Understand before answering ›If it doesn’t go the way you hoped
What they might say, and what you could say back.
If they sayYou never take responsibility for anything.
You could sayI want to take responsibility for this. I’m sorry I wasn’t there.
If they sayAn apology doesn’t change what happened.
You could sayYou’re right, it doesn’t. I’d still like you to know I’m sorry, and I’m listening.
If they sayForget it. You’ll never understand.
You could sayI’d like to try. Could we talk about it when it’s just the two of us?
Putting it together
The whole message, before and after.
What you might want to sayAre we really doing this again? That was fifteen years ago. Get over it.
Porcupine · Own your part“Get over it” tells them their hurt has expired. An apology, a question about what would help and a wish to talk without a fight show it still matters to you.
What might land betterI can tell my missing your graduation still hurts. I’m sorry I wasn’t there, and I wish I had been. What would help now? I’d like us to be able to talk about it without it turning into a fight.
Run a Quills Check on yours
Write what you want to say, however it comes out. I’ll show you if the quills are up, and a version with them down.
The Quills Check needs JavaScript. Please turn it on and reload the page.
Common questions
What if I already apologized?
Sometimes one apology isn’t enough to feel heard. You don’t have to keep apologizing, but you can listen again: “It sounds like it still hurts. Tell me about it.”
What if I remember it differently?
Say so after they feel heard, about what happened rather than who’s right: “I remember it a bit differently. Can I tell you how it looked to me?”
What if they bring it up in front of everyone?
You can say you’d like to talk about it, just not right now: “This matters, and I want to talk about it properly. Can we find a time this week?”
Know someone this would help?
Send them this guide. The link shows its title and one of its examples.
Find the words with Porcupine
PorcupineWhen it comes up again, I’ll remember where you left off and help you answer without reopening the old fight.
Porcupine is coming soon. Sign up to be one of the first to try it.
Just your email. How we handle it
More for the season
- Get through the holidays with your family, without a fightWho goes where, gifts, grandparents and the dinner table, in the order they come up.
Related guides
- How to tell your family you’re not coming home for the holidaysAnyone in the family
- How to handle a family disagreement at the holidaysAnyone in the family
- How to tell your family you want to cut back on giftsAnyone in the family
- How to tell your family you’ve been feeling left outAnyone in the family
Guides are general information, not legal, financial or professional advice. If you’re afraid of how someone might react, put your safety first and talk to someone you trust (Safety first).