What to say instead of “you always” and “you never”
“You always” starts a debate about the exceptions. One example from this time, how it landed and what you’d like next, is something they can actually hear.
Why it backfires
“Always” and “never” are about who someone is, so they end up defending themselves instead of hearing you. One specific moment is something they can answer.
Describe, don’t diagnoseWith friends
Instead ofYou always do this with money.
TryYou still owe $60 for the tickets.
Porcupine · Skip “always” and “never”“You always do this” turns one debt into a pattern. $60 for the tickets is one thing, and easy to settle.
Describe, don’t diagnoseGuide: How to ask a friend to pay you back
With friends
Instead ofYou always have an excuse.
TryHas something been going on? I’d like to know.
Porcupine · Ask real questions“You always have an excuse” rules out a real reason. “Has something been going on?” lets them tell you.
Understand before answeringGuide: What to do when a friendship feels one-sided
With a partner
Instead ofThat would never work.
TryLet’s write that one down too. We can rule things out later.
Porcupine · Show you’re open“That would never work” ends an idea before it’s on the list. “Write that one down too” keeps it, and leaves the judging for later.
Stay openGuide: How to talk with your partner about a big decision you disagree on
With family
Instead ofYou always flake on this stuff.
TryCould you have the invitations out by May 1?
Porcupine · The behavior, not the person“You always flake” brings the past into this party. Asking for the invitations by May 1 is one clear thing they can do.
Describe, don’t diagnoseGuide: How to plan a family event with your siblings
With a partner
Instead ofWe never do anything together.
TryI miss our weekend walks, and talking over dinner.
Porcupine · Skip “always” and “never”“Never” invites a list of the times you did. Weekend walks and talking over dinner are things you both remember, and easy to start again.
Describe, don’t diagnoseGuide: How to tell your partner you’ve been feeling lonely
With a partner
Instead ofYou’re the one who’s always on it.
TryI know I scroll a lot too, especially at night.
Porcupine · Own your part“You’re the one” puts all of it on them. Naming your own scrolling first, and when, shows you’re looking at yourself too.
Own your partGuide: How to talk to your partner about phone use
With family
Instead ofYou never make time for family.
TryYou missed Sunday dinner twice this month, and we missed you.
Porcupine · Skip “always” and “never”“Never” turns two dinners into a verdict on them. Naming the two Sundays, and that you missed them, leaves something you can talk about.
Describe, don’t diagnoseGuide: How to talk to your adult child without arguing
At work
Instead ofLet’s just never do that again.
TryNext time we disagree, could we talk one on one before the meeting?
Porcupine · A clear, doable request“Never do that again” is a hope, not a plan. Talking one on one before the meeting is something you can both actually do next time.
Honest and hearableGuide: How to repair a working relationship after a conflict
With a partner
Instead ofYou never do anything around here. I’m not your maid.
TryI’ve been feeling stretched thin with the house lately, and I’d love to work out a better split with you.
Porcupine · Soft start-up“You never” and “I’m not your maid” open with a verdict. Starting from how stretched you’ve been, and the better split you’d like, invites them in.
Respect, even when angryGuide: How to ask your partner for more help at home
At work
Instead ofWhy does everything always have to be due yesterday?
TryWhat’s driving Friday? If I know what it’s for, I can work out what we could have ready by then.
Porcupine · Ask real questions“Always due yesterday” is a complaint about everything. “What’s driving Friday?” asks about this date, and what it’s for.
Understand before answeringGuide: How to push back on your manager’s deadline
With family
Instead ofYou always have to control everything. I’m an adult!
TryWhen you drop by without calling, it’s hard for me. I’d like you to call first.
Porcupine · The behavior, not the person“You always have to control everything” is a verdict on them. Dropping by without calling is one moment, and calling first is something they can start this week.
Describe, don’t diagnoseGuide: How to set a boundary with your parents as an adult
With family
Instead ofYou always twist what happened.
TryI remember that week a bit differently. Can I tell you how it looked to me?
Porcupine · The behavior, not the person“You always twist what happened” is about them. “I remember it differently” keeps your side about the memory, and asking first makes room for both.
Describe, don’t diagnoseGuide: What to do when a family member keeps bringing up the past
With a partner
Instead ofHere we go again. You’ll never change, will you?
TryI don’t think either of us is going to change completely on this. Can we find a way to live with it that works for both of us?
Porcupine · Accept what won’t change“You’ll never change” is a verdict on them. Saying neither of you will change completely makes it a difference you share, and one you can plan around.
Agreement isn’t the only good endingGuide: How to stop having the same argument over and over
With a partner
Instead ofYou never pay attention to me anymore.
TryI’ve been feeling lonely lately, even when we’re together, and I miss us.
Porcupine · Name the softer feeling“You never pay attention” puts it on them. “Lonely, even when we’re together” says what it’s like for you, and “I miss us” says what you’d like back.
Say what’s underneathGuide: How to tell your partner you’ve been feeling lonely
With a co-parent
Instead ofTypical. You always do this at the last minute and then blame me.
TryI can do pickup at 5 instead of 4 on Friday. Let me know if that works.
Porcupine · Skip “always” and “never”“Typical” and “you always” turn one late change into a pattern. A time, and “let me know,” answer what’s actually in front of you.
Describe, don’t diagnoseGuide: How to communicate with a difficult co-parent
With a roommate
Instead ofYou never clean up after yourself. Do you just expect me to do everything?
TryThe dishes have been piling up this week, and I’ve ended up doing most of them.
Porcupine · Skip “always” and “never”“You never clean up” and “do you just expect me” are about them. A week of dishes, mostly done by you, is what happened.
Describe, don’t diagnoseGuide: How to talk to your roommate about chores
Check yours
Got one of these in a message you’re about to send? Paste it, however it comes out. I’ll show you if the quills are up, and a version with them down.
The Quills Check needs JavaScript. Please turn it on and reload the page.
Instead of…
Say this, not that, with…
Just need the words?
What to say when it’s hard: texts to send after a fight, when someone’s mad at you, and more
Find the words with Porcupine
PorcupineA swap is a start. In a porcupine chat, I’ll help with what they say back, too.
Porcupine is coming soon. Sign up to be one of the first to try it.
We’ll email you when Porcupine opens and when we add new tools. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy
Updated